Communities v Search
Friday, August 3rd, 2007So I have been pondering this a while now and probably will continue to ponder it. What is the best way for teachers to find relevant lesson plan content?
The current model is a search model. Google goes out and assigns PageRank value to the myriad lesson planning sites and based on your search term lists them for your clicking pleasure. Then you, the searcher, begin a search for a plan that is relevant to you based on your particular criteria within these sites. Sometimes you constrain the search based on certain traditional hierarchies (grades, subjects) and sometimes the search is done through a series of search terms. It’s an alright process, I mean it’s the best we’ve got for now, but there must be a better way.
Search is awesome, without Google the web would be a real bummer to navigate. I remember when we first got Internet at my house. I was in fifth grade, I think, and my family had signed us up for the Compuserve service and I would spend a couple minutes reading about cars. After those few minutes, because it wasn’t easy to find what little else was on the Internet, I left and did other stuff. I would say that with the advent of Google I probably spent 4x as much time on the Internet. Interestingly enough my patterns have changed, now I find 60% of what interests me via blog links, Facebook, Last.FM or other communities, which leads me to…
What if you just want to connect with a lesson plan that fits your need? A lesson plan to inspire your next days class. It seems that search falls short. The reason it falls short, is because you are seeking inspiration, not just information. Inspiration is derived by knowing the backstory. It comes when there is a dialogue around a product’s use. Inspiration is found in a community. Communities can append a piece of information with all of that metadata that allows you to envision a plan’s usage in your classroom.
That’s why PlansForUs is built as a social lesson planning platform. We are not a site where people dump lesson plans and a few people pop a couple ratings on a plan. Why was Dan Myer’s lesson plan on measurement downloaded 6,000 times. Well in the first place it was good; actually my wife did a plan similar to Dan’s to teach her 1st graders and it met with similar learning success. In the second place, his blog gave the plan context. Now can every plan have the contextual layers that Dan provides in his blog entry, maybe not. However, a community interacting with a plan and a site tracking these interactions and visualizing these interactions can build those contextual layers.
PlansForUs is a lesson planning tool built on the engine of community and connection. Our motto is “creation through collaboration”, it’s simple but if we can achieve our motto then teaching will no doubt benefit.