What started with the intent of being a comment to Sheryl Nussbaum-Beach’s post on “It Is Still About the Learning…” has now turned into a full post of my own. The numerous blog posts and comments that Sheryl highlighted got me thinking and wondering whether teachers are more apprehensive toward technology than any other group of professionals? And, if so, why? I think there are two aspects to this topic: 1) teachers using technology for their own use and 2) teachers incorporating technology into the course material they teach. Number 2, although not always, could be a natural progression from number 1.
Problems with the adoption of a new product or new piece of technology are not unique to the teaching community. From my experience, a majority of people feel as though they lack the necessary and desired amount of time it takes to become comfortable with a new technology. It was a common complaint that I heard while working with support teams for a couple different credit card processing companies in the past (and these were teams of people dealing with complex software everyday). However, I think, as a software developer, that the technology needs to be more intuitive - especially in the education industry. It is completely unrealistic to place software in the hands of a teacher and expect them (during their off hours) to figure out how to derive value from its use unless it is intuitive enough to require nominal to no training. That same software should also have a clear, positive result from its use - that is, it should either produce enjoyment from its use or produce a higher quality of work in the same or less amount of time.
I had the unfortunate experience of watching my fiance go through a 3 day training seminar on how to use a new IEP management system her school was deploying this past fall. She and her fellow resource teachers were instructed on which error messages they should ignore and how to properly interpret the different status messages. This was absurd! And, it’s no wonder that some of the teachers refuse to use it. Technology must serve a visible purpose if you ever expect non-techies (for the lack of a better word) to naturally adopt to it. When easy-to-use, productive technology becomes the norm rather than the exception, you will see more teachers willingly (and eagerly) use and promote it. Once this happens, it becomes a natural progression for technology to be incorporated into the daily lessons they teach.
There are early adopters in all aspects of life, and the active teachers in the blogosphere are those people. They are more willing to deal with buggy software; more willing to spend a weekend learning how to install widgets on their blog; more willing to read a manual and figure something out on their own. This, in my opinion, is as much related to one’s personality as it is to the generation in which you were raised. Rather than focusing a school’s hopes and efforts on new teachers or on mid-career teachers, why not place it in the teachers who have shown a propensity for being an early adopter? Why not place it in the teachers who are highly respected by their peers and tend to have their actions followed? These are the people who will help force the technology to evolve into a usable tool for the rest of the teaching community. These are the people who will push the envelope and help create a more effective and efficient educational system. These are the people that PlansForUs would love to talk to while we try our best to release an intuitive, easy-to-use, productive utility for the teaching community.
Let me know if you think I am way off base here. Not being a teacher, and not working on a daily basis in a school setting, it’s quite possible that there is a dynamic to the situation that I’m just not aware of…